Hello Professor Rovelli,
It is a very relevant general analysis. I agree to begin with the fact that it exists concrete general theories converging due to their interpretations when they are rational and deterministicv like said Feynmann. I make the same in my model and these 3D spheres , I don t reject the others, I try to converge in sorting and in respecting this determinism if I can...
view entire post
Hello Professor Rovelli,
It is a very relevant general analysis. I agree to begin with the fact that it exists concrete general theories converging due to their interpretations when they are rational and deterministicv like said Feynmann. I make the same in my model and these 3D spheres , I don t reject the others, I try to converge in sorting and in respecting this determinism if I can say. It is what I make with the strings for example because these quantum 3D spheres oscillate, vibrate and are in motions oscillations in a kind of superfluidity considering these 3 main spacetimes . So indeed we learn from each others.
You take the different philosophies of 5 main interpretations, the qubism, the pilot wave,the relational QM, the copenaghen one, the many worlds. All this is about the metaphysics and I have my own idea about these ontological and philosophical intepretations. The real secret is to find after all the origin of the universe and the foundamental objects. I believe that we have personally an eternal infinite consciousness in 0D and this thing has created a central main cosmic sphere , a kind of super matter energy able to sent all kind of informations and it is with 3 main primoridal series of 3D spheres in my model.
You speak about the anti realism and the realism, but maybe all is realist , it is just that we have limitations mainly in technologies, scales, and knowledges. The maths also must be interpretated with wisdom and we must doubt also, I believe strongly that the physics is the main chief orchestra and the maths a tool to prove them, not the opposite. The philosophy can be determinsitic I beleive. It seems that we are inside a project in evolution, it is the meaning of my theory of spherisation.
It is interesting to name these thinkers, Jordan, Heisenberg, Born, Pauli,Dirac, and their works about the quantum mechanics and the probabilities. The have given a road and we can with the maths and good foundamental objects go farer if the maths are well interpreted with their rational realsit sortings I believe. Born has had this nobel prize with his paper and the transitions are indeed relevant.It is the predictions the secret and the good mathematical sortings. The observations also and measurements under this universal partition that unfortunally we don t know. These operators are essential. And the experiments in labs can have relevant resulsts.All seems under a specific universal partition where the maths, numbers, physics, sciences, cosmology respect the universal partition. All is a question of properties and interactions indeed.
We return about these probablities and maths permitting to extrapolate this QM. The objectivity being an important key , that is why the subjective results due to these maths must be always taken with this said deterministic wisdom.
You speak about schrodinger who was one of my favorites with Von neumann and dirac. What is the wave function indeed really and how can we extyrapolate it to converge with this realistic QM with these probablities, observations, measurements. That can give the universal key, I beleive the spheres are this key but of course they are complex in the details. There is an universal link between these cosmological and quantum spheres in logic and the metaphysics and philosophy is correlated, an universal truth can appear. The confusion is the complexity maybe.
How can we converge towards the truths in resume , how to predict correctly, how to sort correctly. It is there that the philosophy, the ontology become essential. How to interpret these limits, these discontinuities, these variables. How to consider this origin of the universe? from fields, from coded particles, have we these strings only in this GR and EFE, have we 3d spheres without extradiemnsions? the answer can be found with a kind of conjecture. The values converge in sorting correctly for me.
You speak about this cat of schrodinger with different interpretations, I have my own ideas about this body mind soul problem , we must consider deeper variables, parameters. The wave functions , fields, and this GR and standard model are not sufficient for me , we must insert , superimpose the two other spacetimes, this space vacuum of this DE and this cold dark matter and the evolution, that will permit to explain our deep unknowns like this QG, the cosmological constant problem, the hard problem of consciousness, and others. The fields and waves seem emergent , not the particles in logic. Maybe the error of many is there, to consider only this GR and the fields like origin general of the reality.
Your idea of S1 , S2, S3 and the events and probabilities is very interesting, how to consider the meanings and values , probabilities indeed. The different interpretations, theories become relevant for the coherences and decoherences if we find the correct philosophy and the foundamental objects .The subjectivity in fact can be objective with the good sortings, rtional and determinsitic. I beleive that the complexity of motions, rotations, oscillations, vibrations of these quantum and cosmological 3D spheres in this superfluidity of these 3 spacetimes is the key. We can interpret with the good partitions the observations with determinism. The empirism, determinism, philosophy, ontology,realism are indeed under this universal partition where several roads converge.
Congrats for this youtube, I liked , that permits to share ideas and interpretations, we search the truths after all.
Regards
view post as summary
Professor Rovelli, at the end the discussions are about the observations and the philosophy. A person asks you about a supreme observer and that we could not even exist without this observation. We arrive at deep philosophical questions. Like I said I consider an infinite eternal consciousness creating a project, a system physical in evolution. The sciences community is divided about this, some...
view entire post
Professor Rovelli, at the end the discussions are about the observations and the philosophy. A person asks you about a supreme observer and that we could not even exist without this observation. We arrive at deep philosophical questions. Like I said I consider an infinite eternal consciousness creating a project, a system physical in evolution. The sciences community is divided about this, some consider a mathematical accident from a kind of infinite heat and after they are divided also , some consider strings in 1D at this planck scale, others points and geonetrodynamics and tensors in the EFE and GR.
Some considers so that it is an accident and others consider that these frequences oscillations are made by a kind of god, I consider like einstein a god of spinoza , a god of nature where we respect the pure determinism. And like you can see I don t consider these strings coming from this infinite heat and extradimensions, but coded particles. I have remarked an enormous ontological and philosophical problem with the fields and strings like origin in all humility. Let s speak freely, we search answers to this universal puzzle and from what we come from. So Let s consider this infinite eternal consciousness like energy in 0D, it is not an infinite heat for me, it is more than this, an energy that we cannot definme, so the question is why this thing that we name god has created this universe? maybe the answer is so simple, this thing was alone and has maybe taken an eternity to create this first central cosmological sphere, this supermatter energy. So why I find an enormous problem in these strings and fields like origin ? it is very simple, if this infinity has been able to create a so complex universe with more than 10000 billions of galaxies, and all this complexity with the stars, planets, moons,BHs, biology, chemistry, evolution with oscillations, so this thing is able in the instant to stop the sufferings or a murderers for example and it was also able to create a more perfect universe quickly, but no we evolve and are inside a kind of closed finite evolutive system where even this consciousness evolves.
So that contredicts the oscillations, fields, vibrations at this planck scale of photons like main primoridal origin. That cannot be the truth for me. On the other sense , the potential is infinite and if this thing sent informations coded from this universal center, so we can respect the evolution , the paradox is that this 0D is connected with all, it is if we had only this 0D and the 3D more the time correlated for the motions. Maybe we are simply inside a project in evolution towards an incredible futur. We create and are tools of optimisation inside this physicality.
What is the meaning of all this metaphysically speaking? we are fractals of this infinite eternal cosnciousness and so probably penrose and hameroff are right about the protoconsciousness or the fact that all is conscious at its level, because we are made of this infinite eternal energy of consciousness simply. The heat and electromagnetism comes from these photons encoded in my mdodel, series finite of 3D spheres having the same finite number than this cosnological finite number, I have calculated it approaches the dirac large number oddly sent from this center, they are just a fuels permitting the light these photons and so to observe, the GR, the electromagnetic forces of our SM, and the heat , but we need others also to balance , the main codes can be in this space vacuum of this DE, and the cold dark matter is the other fuel permitting the antiparticles and the QG even, I have reached it like this.
Philosophically we arrive at a logic about the body mind soul probelm and the continuity, when we die we loose these fuels but not the informations encoded in this space vacuum,, that permits to explain many things this reasoning. The informations and entropies can be linked , I try a road to have the good equations with the works of shannon,Gibbs and Von Neumann but not easy frankly alone. It is about the sortings, encodings, superimposings, synchronisations, time lifes of these informations in considering these 3 main spacetimes, actually we just analyse the GR, but in logic we must superimpose the two others.
We are inside an universe in improvement where an universal partition exists with these spheres 3D I beleive. This 3D and the spheres are simply it seems to me the choice of this infinite eternal consciousness to create the phsycality, why ? I don t know but this shape, geometry is not like the others, it is the perfect equilibrium between forces, it can be deformed and create all shapes witht he poincare conjecture, it permist the optimised motions also, it permits to have a superfluidity with specific series where the space disappears with this dirac large number applied from the center the biggest volumes and fater we apply smaller and we increase the number, the space disappears really. All is in contact in this superfluidity universal of our 3 spacetimes.
view post as summary
this post has been edited by the author since its original submission
report post as inappropriate